Comparison with Modern Alternatives
While highly effective, Raney nickel mesh electrodes are sometimes compared to newer materials:
| Feature | Raney Nickel Mesh Electrode | Modern Alternatives (e.g., Pt/C, Ni-Mo alloys on PTL) |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Low (uses abundant Ni). | High for Pt-based; moderate for advanced Ni alloys. |
| Activity | Very High (geometric area). | Can be higher (Pt) or comparable (advanced alloys). |
| Stability | Good in alkali, but can slowly deactivate (sintering, poisoning). | Pt/C can degrade in alkali; some new alloys offer excellent stability. |
| Surface Area | Extremely high (internal pores). | High, but often from nano-particles on a support. |
| Technology Maturity | Mature, industrial-scale. | Some are emerging (R&D to early commercial). |


